top of page

Episode 4: Back on Track – Written in Red by Anne Bishop (Ch. 1–16)

In this episode of Shelf Esteem Issues, I’m getting us back on track after a messy, off-the-cuff last installment. I realized I jumped ahead without really grounding you in the world of Written in Red by Anne Bishop—the book that kicked off this whole podcast. So this week I slow down, apologize for the chaos, and give you the clear, thoughtful breakdown you deserved from the start.

A World Where Humans Aren’t in Charge

Written in Red flips the usual fantasy script. This is a world where humans are not the dominant species. The land belongs to “the Others”—shapeshifters, vampires, and ancient elemental beings—and humans are allowed to exist only by their permission.

That imbalance of power sets the tone right away. From page one, it’s obvious:

  • The Others hold the real power.
  • Humans survive by following rules they barely understand.
  • Any “authority” humans think they have is borrowed and fragile.

Instead of vampires and werewolves hiding from humans, humans are the ones who should be scared.

Meet Meg Corbyn: A Fragile, Dangerous Kind of Hero

Our main character, Meg Corbyn, is on the run from a human institution called the Controllers. They exploit people like her—prophets who can see the future—but at a terrible cost. Meg’s visions only come when she cuts her own skin, turning her body into a tool other people use.

By the time we meet her, she’s:

  • Traumatized
  • Socially inexperienced
  • Completely unfamiliar with the outside world

She escapes into the cold and ends up at Lakeside Courtyard, a territory run by the Others. Humans can be there only by permission. Meg doesn’t behave like other humans: she doesn’t fear the Others “correctly,” doesn’t follow social rules, and clearly carries deep emotional and physical scars.

Lakeside Courtyard: A Fragile Middle Ground

Lakeside Courtyard is an uneasy in‑between space. It’s technically a place where humans and Others can interact, but:

  • The Others own it and set the rules.
  • Humans are tolerated, not welcomed.
  • One wrong move can mean death.

Meg finds a job there and, for the first time in her life, starts to experience something she’s never really had before: safety. No one locks her in. No one forces visions from her. The “monsters” are actually treating her better than humans ever did.

That contrast drives one of the big questions of the book: Who are the real monsters—humans or the Others?

Simon Wolfgard and the Slow-Burn Tension

Simon Wolfgard, the wolf shifter who leads the Courtyard, becomes a key perspective. From his point of view:

  • Is Simon acting from pack instinct or something deeper?
  • Is Meg becoming part of his “pack,” or is she still just “a human” to him?
  • Can a predator truly protect someone who, by nature, should be prey?

The story doesn’t rush into romance or big declarations. Instead, it builds quiet tension and explores the boundaries of these two very different natures.

Chapters 1–16: Slow Pace, Big Stakes

In chapters 1–16, not a lot “explodes,” but a lot builds. We see:

  • Meg trying to learn normal life: work, conversations, daily routines.
  • The Others struggling to understand her lack of fear and literal way of thinking.
  • Her trauma showing up in subtle ways—her willingness to hurt herself, her difficulty making choices, her inability to picture a future.

The book uses everyday moments—meals, small arguments, misunderstandings—to keep tension simmering. Any small mistake could trigger deadly consequences as the human world closes in.

Big Themes Emerging So Far

  • Control vs. choice—especially over Meg’s body and abilities.
  • Power and restraint—who can be trusted with authority?
  • What it means to be human—and whether “human” automatically equals “good.”
  • The cost of knowledge—Meg’s blood prophecy hurts her every single time.

Meg herself quietly redefines strength. She isn’t strong in a physical or traditional sense. Her strength is surviving captivity, continuing to choose kindness, and moving forward even when she’s afraid. Strength here is endurance, not dominance.

Book Club–Style Questions to Chew On
  1. How does the book change your usual idea of humans being on top in fantasy stories?
  2. Why do Meg’s honesty and confusion unsettle the Others so much?
  3. In what ways do chapters 1–16 show the lasting impact of Meg’s trauma?
  4. Is Simon’s protectiveness instinct, responsibility, or the start of something deeper?
  5. Who feels more dangerous right now: the Others or the human institutions like the Controllers?
  6. What does Meg’s blood prophecy say about the real cost of knowledge?
  7. Is Meg truly safer with the Others, or is her safety just a different kind of fragile?

Where We Leave Off

By chapter 16, pressure is quietly stacking up. Human forces are circling, Meg's abilities are getting harder to hide, and the Courtyard is already bending long-standing rules for her. It’s clear Meg is changing the balance of this world—and there will be a cost when the human world pushes back.

Next time, I’ll be diving into chapters 17–24 to see who tries to claim Meg next and whether peaceful coexistence is even possible.

Until then, my book dragons— “To thine own self be true.” BB

bottom of page